Whites who kill blacks in 'Stand Your Ground' states are 354% more likely to acquitted of murder

Victim: George Zimmerman was accused of murdering the unarmed black teenager Trayvon Martin after following him with a gun last year
  • Drawn from a study using FBI data on homicides between 2005 to 2009
  • 31 states across the U.S. have the 'Stand your Ground' law
  • Florida where Zimmerman shot Trayvon Martin has the self-defence law

By Jill Reilly |

White people who kill black people in 'Stand Your Ground' states are 354 per cent more likely to be found justified in their killing than a white person who kills another white person, according to research.

On Saturday George Zimmerman, 29, was acquitted of second-degree murder and manslaughter in the shooting death of 17-year old-Trayvon Benjamin Martin.

But he was not arrested for 44 days after the February 26, 2012, shooting as police in Sanford insisted that Florida's Stand Your Ground law on self-defence prohibited them from bringing charges - Florida gives people wide latitude to use deadly force if they fear death or bodily harm.

The result was drawn from a study using FBI data conducted by John Roman, a senior analyst at Urban Institute’s Justice Policy Center.

 

He examined racial disparity using data on 43,500 homicides from 2005 to 2009 - the most recent years for which data was available, reported PBS.

He narrowed the sample to about 5,000 homicides by only analysing killings in which there was a single shooter and a single victim, both of whom were strangers to each other.

Breakdown of the killings

Breakdown of the killings: The figures represent the percentage likelihood that the deaths will be found justifiable compared to white-on-white killings

Roman looked specifically at 'justified' homicides - defined as the killing of a felon during the commission of a felony, committed by private citizens.

He discovered that killings of black people by whites were more likely to be considered justified than the killings of white people by blacks.

Frontline then asked him to analyse the data and look for findings between states which had Stand Your Ground versus those without the laws.

Under the Stand Your Ground law, which was approved in 2005 and applies in over 30 states, people fearing for their lives can use deadly force without having to retreat from a confrontation, even when it is possible.

The self-defence law applies in Florida where Zimmerman shot Trayvon Martin dead.

Stand Your Ground graphic.jpg

The court was told that he had followed the unarmed youngster through a park because he looked like he was 'up to no good.'

But Zimmerman, a volunteer neighbourhood watchman, claimed he shot Martin in self-defence, and that the teen punched him repeatedly before deciding to use lethal force.

The statute is central to Zimmerman's defense in a case that captivated the United States throughout much of 2012 because police initially declined to arrest Zimmerman based on his self-defense argument and right to use deadly force under Florida law.

Roman analysed the pool of 43,500 homicides by race in states with Stand Your Ground laws and those without them.  

He found that whites who kill blacks in non-Stand Your Ground states are 250 percent more likely to be found justified in killing a black person than a white person who kills another white person.

But in Stand Your Ground states, that number jumps to 354 percent.

But the findings are not yet conclusive - the data doesn’t show the circumstances behind the killings, for example whether the people who were shot were involved in home invasions or in a confrontation on the street.

Plus there are less white-on-black shootings in the FBI data  -only 25 total in both the Stand Your Ground and non-Stand Your Ground states.

Additionally Stand Your Ground laws can be applied at multiple points during an investigation.

Zimmerman was not arrested for over a month following the shooting as police in Sanford insisted that Florida's Stand Your Ground law on self-defence prohibited them from bringing charges.

A special prosecutor later brought the murder charge.

The prosecutor accused Zimmerman of profiling Martin and chasing him vigilante-style rather than waiting for police to arrive.

Zimmerman left the courthouse as a free man, although the NAACP has called for the Justice Department to open a civil rights case against Zimmerman.

Though the department has a history of using federal civil rights law in an effort to convict defendants who've previously been acquitted in state cases, it's not always easy.

Forceful: Thousands of protestors gathered in Times Square on Sunday night to demonstrate against the acquittal of George Zimmerman in Florida late Saturday. The march continued up 5th Avenue toward Harlem when arrests began

Forceful: Thousands of protestors gathered in Times Square on Sunday night to demonstrate against the acquittal of George Zimmerman in Florida late Saturday. The march continued up 5th Avenue toward Harlem when arrests began

Massive: The crowd of pro-Trayvon Martin protestors swelled in Times Square, where they marched from Union Square on Sunday before continuing uptown

Massive: The crowd of pro-Trayvon Martin protestors swelled in Times Square, where they marched from Union Square on Sunday before continuing uptown

Blocked: With emotions high and traffic stopped, tensions rose as protestors blocked the Los Angeles freeway

Blocked: With emotions high and traffic stopped, tensions rose as protestors blocked the Los Angeles freeway

The department said in a statement Sunday afternoon that it's looking into the case to determine whether federal civil rights charges should be filed.

Supporters have suggested that Martin's parents file a wrongful-death civil lawsuit against Zimmerman.

Zimmerman's lawyers have said he'll seek immunity. Florida's stand your ground law may offer him that immunity if a judge concludes he acted in self-defense, said David Weinstein, a former federal prosecutor in Miami.

Views: 100

Reply to This

Best guide to hip hop, soul, reggae concerts & events in San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles & New York City + music, videos, radio and more

Connect

Bookmark and Share

Subscribe to E-Blast

WIN TICKETS

Steel Pulse
Thursday, Apr 18 @ UC Theatre, Berkeley

Mario Hodge
Saturday, May 4 @ Moose Lodge, El Sobrante

PJ Morton
Wedneday, Oct 23 @ Fox Theater, Oakland

Members

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Groups

Latest Activity

realmuzik posted discussions
1 hour ago
Editor's Pick posted a discussion
2 hours ago
Artistpr posted a blog post

Moneyama: Cameroon-Born Rap Phenom Inspires Fans with Unique Blend of Music and Wellness

Orlando, Florida – MONEYAMA, the dynamic rap artist born in Cameroon, West Africa, is set to make waves in the music industry with his debut release. As a sports-driven athlete and personal trainer, MONEYAMA’s music is infused with his passion for health and wellness, inspiring fans to embrace their inner strength and pursue their dreams. Fans can expect to find MONEYAMA’s tracks on all major streaming platforms starting this month, immersing themselves in his energetic blend of hip hop, dance,…See More
16 hours ago
Editor's Pick posted videos
yesterday
Editor's Pick posted discussions
yesterday
realmuzik posted a discussion

Red Mcfly Drops New Single "No Tomorrow" ft. Rick Hyde of Black Soprano Family, Marks Debut Under Coke Boys Records

Red Mcfly is making waves with his latest release, "No Tomorrow," featuring the talented Rick Hyde of Black Soprano Family. This collaboration marks Red Mcfly's first single since joining the esteemed roster of French Montana's label, Coke Boys Records.With "…See More
yesterday
La Peña Cultural Center updated their profile
Thursday
Editor's Pick posted discussions
Thursday
Artistpr posted a blog post

That moment when you show them what it took to get here….

Chicago/Atlanta, IL/GA — Powerful motivational single “On The Way” by Krys Barry is a whole vibe. That moment when others are made to understand the assignment. Come take the Journey through melodic rhymes with a gritty theme. Officially released 4/12/24, Krys Barry’s “On The Way” is a beautiful addition to the Rap genre. Available on All Platforms. A definite inspiration for anyone listening. Here to make the world believe.        ”Get to the bag. Stay on the grind. I’m on the way.” – Krys…See More
Thursday
29 events by Editor's Pick were featured
Wednesday
Editor's Pick posted events
Wednesday
La Peña Cultural Center is now a member of True Skool Network
Wednesday

© 2024   Created by Ren the Vinyl Archaeologist.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service