YouTube cancels billions of video views after finding they had been 'faked' - but were hackers working for the music industry?

  • Major record labels stripped of more than two billion video views
  • Biggest hit taken by Universal, which alone lost more than one billion
  • 'This was an enforcement of our viewcount policy,' says YouTube

By Damien Gayle

PUBLISHED: 12:58 GMT, 28 December 2012 | DailyMail.co.uk

YouTube viewer figures are doubly valuable to channel owners since it is also the primary way in which the site works out how to share its advertising revenue with partners.

The Daily Dot reported how many of the channels affected - which also include ones belonging to Michael Jackson, Chris Brown and Beyonce, among others - had also had many videos deleted. 

Universal, which previously had dozens of clips on its YouTube channel, has had its offering slashed to just five - none of which are music videos or last more than about a minute and a half.

Sony's page was also left practically bare following the cull, with just three videos left.

The world's biggest recording companies have been stripped of two billion YouTube hits after the website cracked down on alleged 'fake viewers'.

Universal, home of Rihanna, Nicki Minaj and Justin Bieber, lost a total of one billion views in the video site’s biggest ever crackdown on artificially inflated figures.

Sony was second hardest hit, with the label behind such stars as Alicia Keys, Rita Ora and Labrinth losing more than 850million views in a single day.

The dramatic cuts came as YouTube conducted a crackdown on fake views, but music industry sources have blamed it on housekeeping related to the migration of their videos across different channels.

The unprecedented move left Universal with just five videos on the site - none of which were music - and Sony with just three.

'This was not a bug or a security breach. This was an enforcement of our viewcount policy,' YouTube announced.

It marks a huge commercial blow to all the artists involved as YouTube is now the web's most important outlet for music videos

Over four billion hours of video are watched by over 800million unique visitors to the site each month.

The dramatic falls, highlighted by figures compiled by YouTube statistics analysts at SocialBlade, came after YouTube conducted an audit of its viewing figures aimed at combating 'black hat' view count-building techniques.

That is the term used when hackers artificially build up the numbers of views or likes on a YouTube video - enabling them to make clips appear far more popular than they really are and increase their exposure on the site.

The number of views attracted on YouTube are these days regarded as an unofficial worldwide popular music chart, so once it became clear that hits had been inflated, fingers immediately pointed at the record industry.

Among the channels affected was that of British X Factor success story Leona Lewis. The official YouTube channel of the protégé of music industry svengali Simon Cowell, lost nearly 24million page views as a result of the crackdown.

The mass takedowns came the same day that hundreds of the site's users flooded forums to complain they had suffered a series of video deletions for violations of YouTube's terms of service. 

Many speculated they fallen victim to a technical error, but YouTube replied to confirm that the users had been sanctioned for violating TOS item 4, Section H, which bans artificially inflating view counts.

According to the Daily Dot, the apparent crackdown last week was widely discussed on the Black Hat World forum, where visitors exchange advice on unethical search engine optimisation tactics.

In one thread on the forum, where YouTube included a link to the site's policy on 'viewcount gaming, the first post spoke of a 'friend' who 'sells likes' who had been told by four different customers that their videos were deleted due to violations of YouTube's terms of service.

The bigger they come: This graph shows how Universal Music Group lost more than a billion page views in a single day when YouTube carried out its audit on view numbers

The bigger they come: This graph shows how Universal Music Group lost more than a billion page views in a single day when YouTube carried out its audit on view numbers

 

This graph tracks the loss in views suffered by Sony BMG: The label behind such stars as Alicia Keys, Rita Ora and Labrinth lost more than 850million views in a single day

This graph tracks the loss in views suffered by Sony BMG: The label behind such stars as Alicia Keys, Rita Ora and Labrinth lost more than 850million views in a single day

Record labels have blamed the cuts in their viewing figures on a change in the way that YouTube has changed its view count. Billboard reported how the Google-owned company recently decided to remove view counts for so-called 'dead videos', which were no longer live on the channel.

A senior label executive told the music industry trade magazine that since thousands of videos had in fact been migrated to Vevo, the views those clips accrued during their time on their dedicated label channels were taken away in YouTube's 'clean up'.

Universal acknowledged its drop in views, but told the Daily Dot its channel had been mostly dormant since it shifted its focus to Vevo, which it founded in 2009 together with Sony Music, Abu Dhabi Media Company, and E1 Entertainment.

Google declined to comment when contacted by MailOnline.

Commenters on the Sony YouTube channel gloated over the major record labels' apparent comeuppance.

User Lattentreffer posted on SonymusicSME: 'Pretty much f*** you, sonymusic.... Hahahaha.

'You got the axe on your black hat viewcount manipulating....!'
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2254181/YouTube-wipe...
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

Views: 126

▶ Reply to This

Best guide to hip hop, soul, reggae concerts & events in San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles & New York City + music, videos, radio and more

Subscribe to Our E-Blast

WIN TICKETS

Hugel
Saturday, Nov 7 @ Greek Theatre, Berkeley

Bonobo
Saturday, Nov 14 @ Fox Theater, Oakland

Pretty Lights
Thursday-Sunday, Nov 19-21 @ Fox Theater, Oakland

Ozomatli
Saturday, Nov. 21 @ UC Theatre, Berkeley

Connect

Bluesky Instagram TikTok Linktree

Members

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Latest Activity

Editor's Pick posted discussions
19 minutes ago
46 events by Editor's Pick were featured
22 minutes ago
Editor's Pick posted events
22 minutes ago
Editor's Pick shared their discussion on Facebook
1 hour ago
Tampa Mystic posted a blog post

Ace Kahn Turns Life Lessons Into Powerful New Single “Follow the Liter (S4S)”

Detroit, Michigan, has long been a breeding ground for talented artists, producers, and songwriters, and Ace Kahn is making his mark with a sound rooted in personal experiences and authenticity. His latest single, “Follow the Liter (S4S),” delivers a meaningful reflection on life's…See More
18 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Teddy Swims at Chase Center, SF

November 10, 2026 from 7pm to 11pm
Tuesday, November 10, 2026TEDDY SWIMSwith Natasha Bedingfield and MarcLoChase Center500 Terry A Francois Boulevard,San Francisco, CADoors: 6:00pm | Show: 7:00pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Syd at The Castro, SF

December 15, 2026 from 8pm to 11pm
Tuesday, December 15, 2026SYDwith JayminThe Castro429 Castro St,San Francisco, CADoors: 7:00pm | Show: 8:00pmThis event is all ages.>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tyla at Fox Theater, Oakland

November 13, 2026 from 8pm to 11pm
Friday, November 13, 2026TYLAThe A*POP World TourFox Theater1807 Telegraph Ave,Oakland, CADoors: 7:00pm | Show: 8:00pmThis event is all ages. Show moved from Bill Graham Civic Auditorium; original tickets will be honored at the Fox Theater as General Admission.>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

A Tribute to Grover Washington Jr. at Yoshi's, Oakland

November 9, 2026 from 8pm to 11pm
Monday, November 9, 2026A TRIBUTE TO GROVER WASHINGTON JR.feat. Kevin Moore, Angelo Luster, Ashley Jemison and Eldon T. JonesYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CADoors: 7:30pm | Show: 8:00pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tower of Power Residency at Yoshi's, Oakland

February 5, 2027 from 8pm to 11pm
February 5, 6 and 7, 2027TOWER OF POWER RESIDENCYYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CAFriday and Saturday: Doors 7:30pm | Show 8:00pmSunday: Doors 7:00pm | Show 7:30pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tower of Power Residency at Yoshi's, Oakland

January 29, 2027 from 8pm to 11pm
January 29, 30 and 31, 2027TOWER OF POWER RESIDENCYYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CAFriday and Saturday: Doors 7:30pm | Show 8:00pmSunday: Doors 7:00pm | Show 7:30pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tower of Power Residency at Yoshi's, Oakland

January 22, 2027 from 8pm to 11pm
January 22, 23 and 24, 2027TOWER OF POWER RESIDENCYYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CAFriday and Saturday: Doors 7:30pm | Show 8:00pmSunday: Doors 7:00pm | Show 7:30pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago

© 2026   Created by Ren the Vinyl Archaeologist.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service