And why Walmart, McDonald's and every hospital in the country should be unionized

by Robert Reich | Tuesday, January 29, 2013 by RobertReich.org

As President Obama said in his inaugural address last week, America “cannot succeed when a shrinking few do very well and a growing many barely make it.”

Yet that continues to be the direction we’re heading in.

 A newly-released analysis by the Economic Policy Institute shows that the super-rich have done well in the economic recovery while almost everyone else has done badly. The top 1 percent of earners’ real wages grew 8.2 percent from 2009 to 2011, yet the real annual wages of Americans in the bottom 90 percent have continued to decline in the recovery, eroding by 1.2 percent between 2009 and 2011.

In other words, we’re back to the widening inequality we had before the debt bubble burst in 2008 and the economy crashed.

But the President is exactly right. Not even the very wealthy can continue to succeed without a broader-based prosperity. That’s because 70 percent of economic activity in America is consumer spending. If the bottom 90 percent of Americans are becoming poorer, they’re less able to spend. Without their spending, the economy can’t get out of first gear. 

That’s a big reason why the recovery continues to be anemic, and why the International Monetary Fund just lowered its estimate for U.S. growth in 2013 to just 2 percent. 

Almost a quarter of all jobs in America now pay wages below the poverty line for a family of four. The Bureau of Labor Statistics estimates 7 out of 10 growth occupations over the next decade will be low-wage — like serving customers at big-box retailers and fast-food chains.

At this rate, who’s going to buy all the goods and services America is capable of producing? We can’t return to the kind of debt-financed consumption that caused the bubble in the first place.

Get it? It’s not a zero-sum game. Wealthy Americans would do better with smaller shares of a rapidly-growing economy than with the large shares they now possess of an economy that’s barely moving.

If they were rational, the wealthy would support public investments in education and job-training, a world-class infrastructure (transportation, water and sewage, energy, internet), and basic research – all of which would make the American workforce more productive.

If they were rational they’d even support labor unions – which have proven the best means of giving working people a fair share in the nation’s prosperity.

But labor unions are almost extinct.

The decline of labor unions in America tracks exactly the decline in the bottom 90 percent’s share of total earnings, and shrinkage of the middle class.

In the 1950s, when the U.S. economy was growing faster than 3 percent a year, more than a third of all working people belonged to a union. That gave them enough bargaining clout to get wages that allowed them to buy what the economy was capable of producing.

Since the late 1970s, unions have eroded – as has the purchasing power of most Americans, and not coincidentally, the average annual growth of the economy.

Last week the Bureau of Labor Statistics  reported that as of 2012 only 6.6 percent of workers in the private sector were unionized. (That’s down from 6.9 percent in 2011.) That’s the lowest rate of unionization in almost a century.

What’s to blame? Partly globalization and technological change. Globalization sent many unionized manufacturing plants abroad.

Manufacturing is starting to return to America but it’s returning without many jobs. The old assembly line has been replaced by robotics and numerically-controlled machine tools.

Technologies have also replaced many formerly unionized workers in telecommunications (remember telephone operators?) and clerical jobs.

But wait. Other nations subject to the same forces have far higher levels of unionization than America. 28 percent of Canada’s workforce is unionized, as is more than 25 percent of Britain’s, and almost 20 percent of Germany’s.

Unions are almost extinct in America because we’ve chosen to make them extinct.

Unlike other rich nations, our labor laws allow employers to replace striking workers. We’ve also made it exceedingly difficult for workers to organize, and we barely penalized companies that violate labor laws. (A worker who’s illegally fired for trying to organize a union may, if lucky, get the job back along with back pay – after years of legal haggling.)

Republicans, in particular, have set out to kill off unions. Union membership dropped 13 percent last year in Wisconsin, which in 2011 curbed the collective bargaining rights of many public employees. And it fell 18 percent last year in Indiana, which last February enacted a right-to-work law (allowing employees at unionized workplaces to get all the benefits of unionization without paying for them). Last month Michigan enacted a similar law.

Don’t blame globalization and technological change for why employees at Walmart, America’s largest employer, still don’t have a union. They’re not in global competition and their jobs aren’t directly threatened by technology.

The average pay of a Walmart worker is $8.81 an hour. A third of Walmart’s employees work less than 28 hours per week and don’t qualify for benefits.

Walmart is a microcosm of the American economy. It has brazenly fought off unions. But it could easily afford to pay its workers more. It earned $16 billion last year. Much of that sum went to Walmart’s shareholders, including the family of its founder, Sam Walton.

The wealth of the Walton family now exceeds the wealth of the bottom 40 percent of American families combined, according to an analysis by the Economic Policy Institute.

But how can Walmart expect to continue to show fat profits when most of its customers are on a downward economic escalator?

Walmart should be unionized. So should McDonalds. So should every major big-box retailer and fast-food outlet in the nation. So should every hospital in America.

That way, more Americans would have enough money in their pockets to get the economy moving. And everyone – even the very rich – would benefit.

As Obama said, America cannot succeed when a shrinking few do very well and a growing many barely make it.

Views: 45

▶ Reply to This

Best guide to hip hop, soul, reggae concerts & events in San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles & New York City + music, videos, radio and more

Subscribe to Our E-Blast

WIN TICKETS

Hugel
Saturday, Nov 7 @ Greek Theatre, Berkeley

Bonobo
Saturday, Nov 14 @ Fox Theater, Oakland

Pretty Lights
Thursday-Sunday, Nov 19-21 @ Fox Theater, Oakland

Ozomatli
Saturday, Nov. 21 @ UC Theatre, Berkeley

Connect

Bluesky Instagram TikTok Linktree

Members

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Latest Activity

Editor's Pick posted discussions
33 minutes ago
46 events by Editor's Pick were featured
36 minutes ago
Editor's Pick posted events
36 minutes ago
Editor's Pick shared their discussion on Facebook
1 hour ago
Tampa Mystic posted a blog post

Ace Kahn Turns Life Lessons Into Powerful New Single “Follow the Liter (S4S)”

Detroit, Michigan, has long been a breeding ground for talented artists, producers, and songwriters, and Ace Kahn is making his mark with a sound rooted in personal experiences and authenticity. His latest single, “Follow the Liter (S4S),” delivers a meaningful reflection on life's…See More
19 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Teddy Swims at Chase Center, SF

November 10, 2026 from 7pm to 11pm
Tuesday, November 10, 2026TEDDY SWIMSwith Natasha Bedingfield and MarcLoChase Center500 Terry A Francois Boulevard,San Francisco, CADoors: 6:00pm | Show: 7:00pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Syd at The Castro, SF

December 15, 2026 from 8pm to 11pm
Tuesday, December 15, 2026SYDwith JayminThe Castro429 Castro St,San Francisco, CADoors: 7:00pm | Show: 8:00pmThis event is all ages.>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tyla at Fox Theater, Oakland

November 13, 2026 from 8pm to 11pm
Friday, November 13, 2026TYLAThe A*POP World TourFox Theater1807 Telegraph Ave,Oakland, CADoors: 7:00pm | Show: 8:00pmThis event is all ages. Show moved from Bill Graham Civic Auditorium; original tickets will be honored at the Fox Theater as General Admission.>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

A Tribute to Grover Washington Jr. at Yoshi's, Oakland

November 9, 2026 from 8pm to 11pm
Monday, November 9, 2026A TRIBUTE TO GROVER WASHINGTON JR.feat. Kevin Moore, Angelo Luster, Ashley Jemison and Eldon T. JonesYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CADoors: 7:30pm | Show: 8:00pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tower of Power Residency at Yoshi's, Oakland

February 5, 2027 from 8pm to 11pm
February 5, 6 and 7, 2027TOWER OF POWER RESIDENCYYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CAFriday and Saturday: Doors 7:30pm | Show 8:00pmSunday: Doors 7:00pm | Show 7:30pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tower of Power Residency at Yoshi's, Oakland

January 29, 2027 from 8pm to 11pm
January 29, 30 and 31, 2027TOWER OF POWER RESIDENCYYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CAFriday and Saturday: Doors 7:30pm | Show 8:00pmSunday: Doors 7:00pm | Show 7:30pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago
Editor's Pick updated an event
Thumbnail

Tower of Power Residency at Yoshi's, Oakland

January 22, 2027 from 8pm to 11pm
January 22, 23 and 24, 2027TOWER OF POWER RESIDENCYYoshi's510 Embarcadero West,Oakland, CAFriday and Saturday: Doors 7:30pm | Show 8:00pmSunday: Doors 7:00pm | Show 7:30pm>> BUY TICKETSSee More
20 hours ago

© 2026   Created by Ren the Vinyl Archaeologist.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service